| YEAR | HOST CITY | TEAMS | WINNER |
| 2021 | AKRON | PHILADELPIA UGH (0) vs CLEVELAND CONCORDIA (0) (3-2 PK) | PHILADELPHA UGH |
| 2020 | AKRON | CANCELED DUE TO | COVID-19 |
| 2019 | MILWAUKEE SC | CLEVELAND CONCORDIA VS MILWAUKEE SC | MILWAUKEE SC (1-0 OVERTIME) |
| 2018 | PHILADELPHIA | PHILADELPHIA UGH (1) VS MILWAUKEE SC (0) | PHILADELPHIA UGH |
| 2016 | CHICAGO | DETROIT CARPATHIA (3) VS MILWAUKEE SC (3-0) | DETROIT CARPATHIA |
| 2015 | MANSFIELD | CLEVELAND CONCORDIA VS DETROIT CARPATHIA (0-2) | DETROIT CARPATHIA |
| 2014 | CLEVELAND | AKRON GFS VS DETROIT CARPATHIA
(2-3) OT/PK | DETROIT CARPATHIA |
| 2013 | MILWAUKEE | DETROIT CARPATHIA VS MILWAUKEE SC (2-3) OVERTIME | MILWAUKEE S.C. |
| 2012 | MANSFIELD | DETROIT CARPATHIA VS CLEVELAND(1-0) | DETROIT CARPATHIA |
| 2011 | PHILADELPHIA UGH | PHILADELPHIA UGH VS CHICAGO G/W (1–0) | PHILADELPHIA UGH |
| 2010 | AKRON | CLEVELAND CONCORDIA VS CHICAGO G/W (1-0) | CLEVELAND |
| 2009 | DETROIT | DETROIT CARPATHIA VS CLEVELAND(0-1) | CLEVELAND |
| 2008 | CLEVELAND | DETROIT CARPATHIA VS CLEVELAND(1-0) | DETROIT CARPATHIA |
| 2007 | MANSFIELD | CLEVELAND CONCORDIA VS AKRON (1-0) | CLEVELAND |
| 2006 | CHICAGO | DETROIT CARPATHIA VS CLEVELAND (1-0) | DETROIT CARPATHIA |
| 2005 | MANSFIELD | CLEVELAND VS DETROIT CARPATHIA (1-1) OT/PK | DETROIT CARPATHIA |
| 2004 | DETROIT | CLEVELAND VS DETROIT CARPATHIA (0-0) OT/PK | CLEVELAND |
| 2003 | MILWAUKEE | CHICAGO G/W VS DETROIT CARPATHIA (1-0) | CHICAGO G/W |
| 2002 | CLEVELAND | DETROIT CARPATHIA VS ST. LOUIS G/W (1-1) OT/PK | DETROIT CARPATHIA |
| 2001 | AKRON | AKRON VS CLEVELAND (1-0) OT | AKRON GFS |
| 2000 | MANSFIELD | DETROIT CARPATHIA VS CLEVELAND (3-1) | DETROIT CARPATHIA |
| 1999 | PHILADELPHIA | CHICAGO G/W VS DETROIT CARPATHIA (0-0) OT/PK | CHICAGO G/W |
| 1998 | DETROIT | CHICAGO G/W VS MILWAUKEE SC (2-0) | CHICAGO G/W |
| 1997 | CLEVELAND | AKRON VS CLEVELAND (2-1) | AKRON GFS |
| 1996 | CHICAGO | CHICAGO G/W VS AKRON (3-0) | CHICAGO G/W |
| 1995 | MANSFIELD | CHICAGO G/W VS DETROIT CARPATHIA (0-0) OT/PK | CHICAGO G/W |
| 1994 | AKRON | AKRON VS CLEVELAND (3-1) | AKRON GFS |
| 1993 | MILWAUKEE | MILWAUKEE SC VS CLEVELAND (1-0) | MILWAUKEE SC |
| 1992 | CLEVELAND | MILWAUKEE SC VS ST. LOUIS G/W (2-1) | MILWAUKEE SC |
| 1991 | ST. LOUIS | AKRON VS ST. LOUIS G/W (2-1 OT) | AKRON GFS |
| 1990 | PHILADELPHIA | PHILADELPHIA GER/HUNG VS CHICAGO G/W (2-1) | PHILADELPHIA GER/HUNG |
| 1989 | MANSFIELD | AKRON VS CLEVELAND (1-0) | AKRON GFS |
| 1988 | CHICAGO | PHILADELPHIA DANUBIA VS MILWAUKEE (1-0) | PHILADELPHIA DANUBIA |
| 1987 | CLEVELAND | PHILADELPHIA DANUBIA VS CLEVELAND (4-3) | PHILADELPHIA DANUBIA |
| 1986 | AKRON | NO FINAL (PLAYOFF POINT SYSTEM) | CHICAGO G/W |
| 1985 | PHILADELPHIA | AKRON VS DETROIT CARPATHIA (2-0) | AKRON GFS |
| 1984 | DETROIT | CHICAGO G/W VS PHILADELPHIA DANUBIA (2-1) | CHICAGO G/W |
| 1983 | MILWAUKEE | PHILADELPHIA DANUBIA VS CLEVELAND (1-1) OT / PK | CLEVELAND |
| 1982 | CLEVELAND | NIAGARA FALLS VS DETROIT CARPATHIA (2-1) | NIAGARA FALLS |
| 1981 | CHICAGO | MILWAUKEE VS CLEVELAND (3-2) | MILWAUKEE SC |
| 1980 | AKRON | NIAGARA FALLS VS AKRON (1-1) OT/PK | NIAGARA FALLS |
| 1979 | MILWAUKEE | NO FINAL (TOTAL POINT SYSTEM) | CLEVELAND |
| 1978 | PHILADELPHIA | NO FINAL (TOTAL POINT SYSTEM) | CLEVELAND |
| 1977 | CLEVELAND | PHILADELPHIA DANUBIA VS CLEVELAND (3-2) OT | PHILADELPHIA DANUBIA |
| 1976 | CHICAGO | MILWAUKEE SC VS DETROIT CARPATHIA (2-0) | MILWAUKEE SC |
| 1975 | AKRON | NO FINAL DUE TO FLOODED FIELD AND HEAVY RAIN * | CHICAGO G/W |
